The nerds and the jocks, the saga continues

Recently, after reading another blog, I was reminded of this issue. There are jocks and there are nerds. The jocks are popular and influential. They like to run the show and order others around. Nerds, on the other hand, are not popular. They are not good at running the show, but they make everything else runs smoothly. They tend to be the backroom boys and the behind-the-scene people that make sure things work.

Image from Revenge of the Nerds movie

The one place where the nerds use to hold their own was the academic world. They are particularly excellent at figuring out how things work and therefore they thrived in the sciences. Much of what we know about the physical world is thanks to the nerds who passionately, tenaciously and meticulously studied the physical phenomena.

That was how things were up until roughly the second world war. Then their knowledge started to have a big enough impact that they appeared on the radar screen of the jocks. So, the jock said to themselves, “Wait a minute, what is going on here? Why are we not aware of this?” And so the jocks started to infiltrate the academic scene.

Today the situation is very different. The jock are running the show in the academic world. They are involved in academic research. The most prominent academic are, with almost no exception, all jocks.

Make no mistake, the jocks are not stupid. They are good enough to maintain successful academic programs. In fact, the way that currently works has to a large extent been invented by the jocks. The funding process, the way academics are currently recruited, and even the way publications are evaluated and judged for suitability are based on the methods typical of the way that jocks would run things. It’s all based on popularity, impact and influence.

However, the jock are not as good at academic research as the nerds are. The consequences can be seen in the lack of progress in fundamental research. You see, jocks are more concerned about their egos and they are only doing this research thing for the fame and glory that first popped onto their radar at the time of the second world war. They are not primarily interested to gain an understanding. No, it is all about the glory. Ostensibly, the goal is still to gain the understanding, and for that the reward comes with all the fame and glory. However, when the reward and goal is not one and the same thing, it is always possible to reap the reward without achieving the goal. This is something I call rewardism.

For the nerds, the understanding itself is the reward. Anything less is simply not good enough. Sure, it is good to receive recognition, but that is not the reason for getting up in the morning.

So, the more I think about the situation in fundamental physics, the more convinced I become that the reason for the lack of progress is at least partly due to the bloated egos of those people running the show there. There may still be some nerds that are actively trying the figure out how nature works, but they are marginalized to the point of being totally ignored. Instead, we have all these people with their crazy predictions and unjustified inventions, that has reached the point where they even consider dispensing with the scientific method itself.

I don’t see how this will ever change. Perhaps several generations need to pass to weed out the jocks by depriving them of the fame and glory that they were hoping for. Then the nerds can come back and pick up where they left off. Who knows? I won’t be around by then.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 1C7DB1746CFC72286DF097344AF23BD2.png

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.